|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Breaking the Circle. Dharmakīrti's Response to the Charge of Circularity Against the Apoha Theory and its Tibetan Adaptation |
|
|
|
| Author |
Hugon, P.
|
|---|
| Source |
Journal of Indian Philosophy
|
|---|
| Volume | v.37 n.6 |
|---|
| Date | 2009.12 |
|---|
| Pages | 533 - 557 |
|---|
| Publisher | Springer |
|---|
| Publisher Url |
http://www.springer.com/gp/
|
|---|
| Location | Berlin, Germany [柏林, 德國] |
|---|
| Content type | 期刊論文=Journal Article |
|---|
| Language | 英文=English |
|---|
| Keyword | Epistemology; Theory of language; Nominalism; apoha; Circularity; Dharmakīrti; Sa skya Pa??ita |
|---|
| Abstract | This paper examines the Buddhist’s answer to one of the most famous (and more intuitive) objections against the semantic theory of “exclusion” (apoha), namely, the charge of circularity. If the understanding of X is not reached positively, but X is understood via the exclusion of non-X, the Buddhist nominalist is facing a problem of circularity, for the understanding of X would depend on that of non-X, which, in turn, depends on that of X. I distinguish in this paper two strategies aiming at “breaking the circle”: (i) conceding the precedence of a positive understanding of X, from which a negative understanding (i.e., the understanding of “non-X”) is derived by contrast, and (ii) denying any precedence by proposing a simultaneous understanding of both X and non-X. I consider how these two options are articulated respectively by Dharmakīrti in his Pramā?avārttika cum Svav?tti and by one of his Tibetan interpreters, Sa skya Pa??ita, and examine the requirements for their workability. I suggest that Sa skya Pa??ita’s motivation to opt for an alternative solution has to do with his criticism of notions shared by his Tibetan predecessors, an outline of which is given in Appendix 1. In Appendix 2, I present the surprising use of the charge of circularity by an early Tibetan logician against his coreligionists. |
|---|
| ISSN | 00221791 (P); 15730395 (E) |
|---|
| Hits | 273 |
|---|
| Created date | 2011.04.07 |
|---|
| Modified date | 2019.07.29 |
|---|
 |
Best viewed with Chrome, Firefox, Safari(Mac) but not supported IE
|
|
|
