|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Wŏnhyo’s Antinomic Inference and Wengui |
|
|
|
| 著者 |
Tang, Ming-jun (著)=湯銘鈞 (au.)
|
|---|
| 掲載誌 |
International Journal of Buddhist Thought & Culture=국제불교문화사상사학회
|
|---|
| 巻号 | v.29 n.2 |
|---|
| 出版年月日 | 2019.12 |
|---|
| ページ | 41 - 68 |
|---|
| 出版者 | International Association for Buddhist Thought and Culture |
|---|
| 出版サイト |
http://iabtc.org/
|
|---|
| 出版地 | Seoul, Korea [首爾, 韓國] |
|---|
| 資料の種類 | 期刊論文=Journal Article |
|---|
| 言語 | 英文=English |
|---|
| ノート | Author Affiliations: Fudan University |
|---|
| キーワード | Buddhist logic; Wŏnhyo; wengui; P’an piryang non; inference of consciousness-only |
|---|
| 抄録 | In the history of the East Asian tradition of Buddhist logic, Wŏnhyo 元曉 is famous for his antinomic inference directed against Xuanzang’s inference of consciousnessonly. Recently, studies by Shigeki Moro (2017) have brought to light the close relation between Wengui 文軌 and Wŏnhyo. By examining the passage from Wengui found by Moro and related materials, I attempt to reveal some new facts concerning the relation between Wengui and Wŏnhyo. In short, Wŏnhyo’s antinomic inference was known to Wengui, as he has offered a criticism on it. Furthermore, Zenju 善珠 in his Inmyō ronsho myōtō shō 因明論疏明燈抄 cites a passage from Wŏnhyo’s P’an piryang non 判比量論, which shows that Wengui’s criticism was known to Wŏnhyo because Wŏnhyo response. The point of Wŏnhyo’s counter is that his inference will be free from fault, as pointed out by Wengui, if the property to be proven in his inference is reformulated into the condition of being separate from the visual consciousness that is well established
(離極成眼識). Lastly, I entertain the hypothesis that the former part of Wengui’s Yinming ru zhengli lun shu 因明入正理論疏, which is actually the source of Wŏnhyo’s knowledge of the inference of consciousness-only was written before the arrival of the antinomic inference in China, while the last part of this same work, which contains criticism of the antinomic inference, was written after the arrival of the antinomic inference. |
|---|
| 目次 | Abstract
Introduction 43
Wŏnhyo’s Antinomic Inference: A Brief Appraisal 44
Wengui’s Criticism of the Antinomic Inference 46
Wŏnhyo’s Response: Texts 51
Wŏnhyo’s Response: Interpretation 56
Concluding Reflections 61
References 67 |
|---|
| ISSN | 15987914 (P) |
|---|
| DOI | 10.16893/IJBTC.2019.06.29.2.41 |
|---|
| ヒット数 | 178 |
|---|
| 作成日 | 2021.03.10 |
|---|
| 更新日期 | 2021.03.10 |
|---|
 |
Chrome, Firefox, Safari(Mac)での検索をお勧めします。ＩＥではこの検索システムを表示できません。
|
|
|
