Phya Pa Chos Kyi Seng Ge and His Successors On the Classification Of Arguments By Consequence (Thal ʾGyur) Based On the Type Of the Logical Reason

Hugon, Pascale (著)

作者

Hugon, Pascale (著)

出處題名

Journal of Indian Philosophy

卷期

v.44 n.5

出版日期

2016.11

頁次

883 - 938

出版者

Springer

出版者網址

http://www.springer.com/gp/

出版地

Berlin, Germany [柏林, 德國]

資料類型

期刊論文=Journal Article

使用語言

英文=English

關鍵詞

Phya pa Chos kyi seng ge; thal ʾgyur; 'gal ba; Arguments by consequence; Buddhist logic; Typology of logical reasons

Introduction 884
1. Phya pa’s Classification of Consequences Based on the Type of the Logical Reason 887
1.1 Phya pa’s Typology of Logical Reasons in Inference 889
1.2 The Twelve Types of Apprehension of Something Incompatible 890
1.3 The “Capable Unimpeded Cause” (rgyu nus pa thogs med) 895
1.4 Symmetric Reasons 896
1.5 Classification According to the Relation 896
1.6 Types of Reasons Excluded from the Range of Consequences 897
2. Classification of Consequences by Phya pa’s Successors 899
2.1 mTshur ston gZhon nu seng ge 899
2.2 gTsang nag pa brTson ʾgrus seng ge 902
a. Text of gTsang nag pa’s bsDus pa in parallel with mTshur ston’s sGron ma 903
b. Essential Property as a Symmetric Reason 906
3. Four Arguments by Consequence and the Divergent Identification of the Type of Their Logical Reason in Three Madhyamaka Works of Phya pa 908
3.1 Phya pa’s Four Arguments by Consequence 910
a. The Formulation of the Opponent’s View 910
b. The Pattern of the Arguments 910
c. The Formulation of the Consequences 910
Qualification of the subject 920
Pervasion 921
3.2 Phya pa’s Arguments by Consequence and the Arguments in the Saṃdhinirmocanasūtra 922
a. 922
b. 923
3.3 Precedents for Phya pa’s Discussion in the Works of rGya dmar ba 925
3.4 Explained and Unexplained Variations 928
Conclusion 929

ISSN

00221791 (P); 15730395 (E)

DOI

10.1007/s10781-015-9285-4

點閱次數

265

建檔日期

2019.10.19

更新日期

2023.10.11